Howeowner ResourceInvesting February 5, 2023

Turning your investment property into an Airbnb: Is it for you?

Turning your investment property into an Airbnb: Is it for you? As you try to figure out the best path for your investment property, you may be bombarded with different options. With the right strategy, it can reap great financial benefits. But, with so many options available, it can be challenging to determine which path is the best for you.

One option that has gained popularity in recent years is turning an investment property into an Airbnb rental. This model offers many benefits, but it also comes with its own set of risks and challenges. Here, we will explore the pros and cons of turning an investment property into an Airbnb rental and hopefully help you determine if it’s the right choice for you.

Villa with a pool. Kitchen is open to the living room and pool area.

The pros of turning your investment property into an Airbnb:

High potential for rental income

Airbnb rentals can often generate higher rental income than traditional long-term rentals. This is because Airbnb rentals are typically rented out on a short-term basis. Short-term basis allows the owner to charge a premium for the convenience and flexibility of the space.

Increased flexibility

Unlike long-term rentals, which typically require a lease agreement that binds the tenant to the property for a set period of time, Airbnb rentals offer much greater flexibility. Property owners can choose when to make their property available for rent. They can easily change the rental amount depending on the season, local events, and other factors that impact demand.

Small log cabin surrounded by pine trees and a hammock in front of it.

Potential for increased property value

With the rise of Airbnb, many areas have seen a surge in property values as buyers look to cash in on the potential rental income from Airbnb rentals. This can be particularly true in tourist-heavy areas where Airbnb rentals are in high demand.

Ability to leverage local knowledge

As the owner of an Airbnb rental, you have a unique opportunity to leverage your local knowledge to provide a more enjoyable experience for your guests. This can include offering recommendations for local attractions, restaurants, and events, or providing insider tips on the best places to visit in the area.

Overhead view of Bear Mountain, Bear Mountain Bridge, and the Hudson River

The cons of turning your investment property into an Airbnb:

Increased competition

As Airbnb becomes more popular, the competition for rental properties is increasing. This means that property owners need to be proactive in promoting their listings and ensuring they stand out from the crowd.

More complex regulations

Turning an investment property into an Airbnb rental can involve navigating a more complex regulatory environment. This includes dealing with local zoning and licensing regulations, as well as taxes and insurance requirements.

Mouse, mug and laptop on top of tax paperwork.

Increased responsibility

As the owner of an Airbnb rental, you are responsible for ensuring that your property is well-maintained and in good condition. This includes regular cleaning and dealing with maintenance issues. You would also have to ensure that the property is equipped with the necessary amenities and furnishings to provide a comfortable stay for your guests.

Potential for decreased property value

In some areas, Airbnb rentals have been associated with a decline in property values. This is particularly true in areas where the influx of short-term renters has disrupted the local community and led to increased noise, traffic, and other issues.

Some locations and property types don’t work

Long term rentals can be placed anywhere, but Airbnb’s cannot. Locations for Airbnb’s are highly important if you want to reap great returns. It should be in close proximity to attractions or destinations that have a good influx of visitors. The location should also be easy to get to from the Airbnb. Property types and amenities can affect reservations as well. Some rentals won’t get as many reservations as others due to their layout or lack of amenities, unlike with long term rentals, which wouldn’t matter as much.

Broken down and falling apart shack.

Is turning your investment property into an Airbnb for you?

Turning an investment property into an Airbnb rental can be a lucrative and rewarding strategy, but it also comes with its own set of challenges. Before making the decision to turn your investment property into an Airbnb rental, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons. Consider factors before going this route, such as local market conditions, competition, and regulations. It’s also important to be well-prepared and informed. This includes researching local taxes, investing in quality furnishings and familiarizing yourself with the area and local attractions.

Ultimately, the decision to turn your investment property into an Airbnb rental will depend on your personal goals and circumstances. If you’re looking for a flexible and potentially high-income investment opportunity, Airbnb rentals can be a great choice. But if you’re looking for a more stable, long-term investment, traditional long-term rentals may be a better option.

If you're ready to start investing, connect with me! Alisha Anglin-Pagan, 718-930-0809, Alisha.pagan@randrealty.com, 229 NY 32, Central Valley, NY 10917